FREE DELIVERY ON ALL ORDERS IN ROMANIA!
An open metal fire pit with burning logs in a garden at sunset

Fire pit or clay garden chiminea: which to choose for your garden and terrace

If you have a big garden and want to grill or cook in a cauldron and sit in a circle around the fire, choose an open fire pit. If you have a terrace or a small garden, the wind blows often or the neighbours are close, a clay garden chiminea is a better fit: the fire burns enclosed, the sparks stay in the bowl and the smoke rises up the chimney.

When you search for an “outdoor fire pit”, a “garden fire bowl” or a “fire ring”, you find almost nothing but open metal bowls. The clay garden fireplace, which you may know as a chiminea, does the same job, holding a wood fire in the open air, but it does it differently. Below we compare them honestly, point by point, so you can choose what suits you, not what we sell.

What is an open fire pit and what is a clay chiminea?

An open fire pit is a bowl, ring or basket made of metal, cast iron or stone, in which the fire burns in full view, with nothing above it. Heat and smoke go off freely in every direction.

A clay garden chiminea is a wide-bellied vessel with a front mouth and a vertical chimney. The fire burns inside, air enters through the front opening and the chimney draws the smoke upwards. Sparkle Stone chimineas are handmade from 100% natural clay, stand 87 cm tall together with the three-legged stand and come with a protective lid. If you’re choosing between two enclosed fireplaces, clay or metal, the comparison is in the article clay or cast-iron garden chiminea.

Which one heats better?

An open fire pit gives off strong heat, but only to those sitting close to the flame. Much of the heat rises straight up, where nobody is sitting, and when the flame dies down, the area around it cools quickly too.

A clay chiminea works like a small outdoor stove: the heat comes out through the front mouth, towards where you’re sitting, and the clay walls heat up and radiate steadily, even after the flame has calmed down. On a terrace or in a corner of the garden, this directed warmth matters more than a big flame.

Smoke and sparks: where is the biggest difference?

This is where the difference is clearest. With an open fire pit, the smoke follows the wind, usually towards whoever is sitting on the opposite side, and sparks fly freely. In a clay chiminea, the fire burns in the belly of the vessel, the wide bowl keeps the sparks inside and the chimney draws the smoke upwards.

There is no wood fire without smoke, with either one. With dry hardwood and small loads, the smoke drops a lot in both. What to burn and how is in the guide what to burn in a garden chiminea.

Which is safer near the house, children and pets?

An enclosed fire is easier to keep under control. In a clay chiminea, the flame and the embers stay behind ceramic walls, and the protective lid goes on when the chiminea is cold, between uses. An open fire pit needs more free space around it, windless days and constant attention for as long as it burns.

Whichever you choose, the basic rules are the same: a non-combustible surface, such as concrete slabs, stone or brick, nothing above the fire, and distance from walls, wooden fences and fabric furniture. For the clay chiminea we cover them all in the article where to place your garden chiminea. And the outside of the clay gets hot, so don’t touch it while the fire is burning.

What can you cook on?

Here the open fire pit wins. If you want a fully loaded grill, a cauldron or a big pan over the fire, you need an open bowl or ring with a grate or tripod above it.

On a clay chiminea you can cook simply, over the embers: skewers, potatoes or vegetables in foil, bread on a stick. The wide bowl takes wood and, in moderation, charcoal, but a heavy grill placed over the mouth of the vessel overloads the ceramic. If cooking is the main reason you want a fire in the garden, be honest with yourself about it from the start.

Maintenance, winter and lifespan

  • A metal fire pit stays outside all year and handles big fires, but it rusts and warps over time, especially if it holds water.
  • A clay chiminea never rusts, but it needs curing at the first lighting, with sand in the bottom and a few small fires, then moderate fires, the lid on between uses and dry shelter in winter, so the water in the clay doesn’t freeze. The details are in the guide to caring for a clay chiminea.

How much space do you need?

A fire bowl makes sense when you have room to put the chairs in a circle, at a distance, with free space on every side. A clay chiminea takes up little room: it stands on its three-legged stand and the heat comes from one side only, so the chairs go in a semicircle in front of the mouth. That’s why it fits on a terrace or in a corner of the garden where an open fire would be too close to the house. And it’s easy to move from one spot to another once it is completely cold.

In short: which should you choose?

  • A big garden, a campfire for lots of people, a grill or a cauldron: an open fire pit.
  • A terrace or small garden, wind, neighbours close by, children around: a clay garden chiminea, with the fire enclosed and the smoke sent up the chimney.
  • You want it to look good by day too, unlit: the clay chiminea, a handmade ceramic piece with raised ornaments.
  • You want to build your own fire pit from brick or stone: see our guide on how to set up a fire pit in the garden.

If the clay option suits you, see our clay garden chimineas: the model with red ornaments and the one with blue ornaments, both with lid and stand included. The current price is on each product page. And if, after this comparison, you realise you need an open fire pit, that’s a good choice too, just for a different garden.

Which heats better, an open fire pit or a clay chiminea?

An open fire pit heats strongly, but only those sitting close to the flame. A clay chiminea sends the heat out through the front mouth, and the hot clay radiates it steadily, even after the flame dies down.

Can I grill or cook in a cauldron on a clay garden chiminea?

Only simple cooking over the embers: skewers, vegetables or potatoes in foil. For a fully loaded grill or a cauldron, an open fire pit is the right choice.

Can I put a fire pit or a clay chiminea on a wooden deck?

Not directly on the boards. Both need to stand on a non-combustible area of concrete slabs, stone or brick, with no roof or branches above.

Does a clay chiminea make smoke?

Yes, like any wood fire. The difference is that the chimney draws the smoke upwards, and with dry wood and small loads there is little smoke.

Secure payment
Customer support
Fast dispatch
Free delivery